Skip to main content

India and Its Raymond Davises

At first sight, the killing of two Indian fishermen by Italian marines off the coast of Kerala and the murder of three Pakistanis by an American government official exactly about a year ago seem to be starkly different.

However, scratch the surface and the similarities can be startling:

  • There was an absolute denial of wrongdoing on the part of the accused (for obvious reasons) – the American, Raymond Davis, which it would be revealed later that he was a covert CIA agent, claimed that he fired in self-defence; the Italian marines, too, made a similar claim, despite others aboard the fishing trawler asserting that they weren’t in possession of arms. Note that Indian fishermen are not allowed by law to carry arms.

  • Davis and the marines, despite their “innocence”, were incarcerated swiftly. Their respective homelands, the USA and Italy respectively, swung into action, demanding their immediate release citing international human rights and UN conventions – wonder what happened to them when the incidents occurred. The US (and the NATO) threatened Pakistan of dire consequences; hyperbole of a healthy bilateral relationship going sour abounded the Pentagon’s media rooms. Italian officials of various hues and ranks have landed in Indian shores, not to mention the opening of dedicated diplomatic channels, to extricate the two sailors.

  • Repulsive as this statement may seem, politics has had a role to play in both the incidents: following Davis’ lodging in the Kot Lakhpat jail in Lahore, the Pakistani government virtually cut off all communication with its ‘ally’ against terror, the US. The ISI, the power bearer sans responsibility, was content at playing second-fiddle throughout, leaving the corruption-besieged PPP government to field inconvenient questions about its next action against Davis. Already in India, the UPA-led government at the Centre has indicated that the issue would be left to its Kerala counterpart, when it ought to be at the forefront.

  • And then there has been the curious case of a newly consecrated Kerala Cardinal making a slew of unfortunate statements, among his notable gaffes of utterances (or was it malice?) being he will “ask the government not to act in haste”, “the primary opposition party in Kerala (the CPM) would derive mileage out of the incident” and “errors were made as fishermen were mistaken for pirates”. The icing on this ignominious cake came from his reported statements that his heart went out to the Catholic fishermen who died and that he would pursue the issue with Catholic ministers of the Kerala Cabinet. Probably his heart would not have melted had the fishermen belonged to another religion, or maybe, Christian sect?
    If ever Italy was looking for someone to advocate their cause, it must verily be him.
    True, the Cardinal may have disowned the statements; the media house may have issued an apology  — but the damage was already done.

  • In Pakistan, the wife of one of Davis’ victims committed suicide, worried that she may not be provided adequate compensation. In an alarming corollary, the wife of one of the Indian fisherman has petitioned a court stating that she needs a compensation of Rs one crore and that she will not be able to foot the litigation expenses.

  • The Pakistani government had to do a balancing act between appeasing public sentiment and complying with the US, albeit grudgingly. Davis was eventually released, but not before ‘blood money’ was provided to the kin of the deceased. Of course it had the leverage of access to its hinterland to Afghanistan which it could use as a pawn against the US. Italy is no US and we do not need any leverage to assert our authority against foreigners committing crimes on Indian soil or waters.

  • This brings us to a vital aspect of our international diplomacy. Politeness is our forte; we abide by the dictum ‘athithi devo bhava’, but we must also have the gumption to assert that others’ nose ends where ours begin. Our track record in this regard isn’t too inspiring. For instance, during 26/11, we let Mossad and FBI agents walk all over our crime spots; the US is still debating whether it needs to extradite David Headley to India, whose involvement in a host of terror activities has been conclusively proved. Portugal has flatly refused to extradite Abu Salem. However, by accommodating the Italians in the investigation into the incident, we are not covering ourselves with glory.
We can make a beginning by awarding the right punishment to the reckless sailors. Italy can choose to bar olive oil and pasta export to our country.

Popular posts from this blog

Chennai’s Fourth Estate at War

Touching upon competitive spirit, the legendary writer George Orwell, in an essay dated 1945, had described sport as war minus the shooting. He could very well be referring to the ongoing veiled battle between two of India's English dailies.

When “India’s national newspaper since 1878” and the “Largest read English daily in the world” decide to slug it out over Chennai’s newspaper readership, rest assured that the battle would spill over to the TV media, as was witnessed recently. Cheeky indeed were the ads that thumbed the nose at one another; though, few were in doubt over who the target was.

To the uninitiated, the two newspapers – The Hindu and The Times of India(TOI), respectively – have modus operandi that are as identical as chalk is to cheese, or uppu (salt) is to upma, a South Indian snack. The "war" in question is the race to get hold of the average Chennaiite, and eventually the Indian, newspaper reader’s attention.

And no, this piece of opinion isn’t about the…

7am arivu: Chennai-China Medley Falls Flat

Should ever a book titled ‘The Art of Deception by Flattery’ be authored, A R Murugadoss’ 7 am arivu (the seventh sense) would probably rank atop in its index; it could even be a case study on how to crash land viewers’ expectations after building it up to a crescendo.
The movie begins with a flashback, when we are told that a Pallava princeling (Surya) migrated to China and became the Shaolin master we know today as Bodhidharma. 
Cut to the present. Subha Srinivasan (Shruti Hasan – actor Kamal Hasan’s daughter making her Tamil debut) is a student of genetic engineering whose research causes the jitters to the People’s Republic of China, forcing them to send a spy, Dong Lee (Hollywood actor Johnny Nguyen, who was also a stunt double in Spiderman and Spiderman-2) to bump her off and spread an epidemic in India. (Are we taking a cue from Hollywood, which during the Cold War era vilified then USSR?) Thrown in the conundrum is Aravind (Surya again) a circus artiste, who falls head-over-hee…

Tamil Nadu’s Thala-Thalapathy conundrum